EXTERNAL AFFAIRS MINISTRY

pm-modi-&-jaishankar:-choice,-coincidences-and-chemistry

PM Modi & Jaishankar: Choice, coincidences and chemistry

Subrahmanyam Jaishankar (Retd IFS:1977), former External Affairs Secretary and a Padma Shri awardee, has brought quite a surprising element to NaMo Govt 2.0. In the past too he has been kicking off one surprise after the other. So a look at Jaishankar’s journey through the events that led to the peak of a career that is simply incredible:

 

First and foremost, he was the first choice of former PM Dr Manmohan Singh for the top job of India’s Ambassador to US (during civil nuke deal). When Narendra Modi took over, Jaishankar became the first choice of PM for Foreign Secretary. People in power corridors are abuzz of Jaishankar’s competence, contributions, attributes and ascent that more than once turned the choice to him irrespective of the change in political leadership of the country.

 

And there are yet a few more interesting coincidences:   

 

Jaishankar first displaced Foreign Secretary Sujata Singh (SS) to occupy the coveted post and later stepped into the shoes of foreign minister Sushma Swaraj (SS). Thus, he replaced one lady after the other and both have the initials SS – a strange coincidence.

 

Soon after he was announced to be part of Modi Cabinet news reports referred to him as retired Foreign Secretary. Most reporters forgot that he had joined the Tatas only few days after his superannuation. His entry to the top business house virtually laid a new precedent. And it is akin to the practice of revolving door which is common in the US. He was a Tata man for 18 months before becoming Minister; a new sort of lateral entry into the Cabinet? 

 

Jaishankar’s coming to the political executive is like that of Manmohan Singh when he suddenly became FM. Singh also went on to become PM. So who can say what is in store in case of Jaishankar?

 

Leave this aside for a moment and look at PM Modi’s spiritual connection with Shankar. The PM has twice been elected from Varanasi, the holy land of Shankar or Baba Vishwanath. During Modi 1.0 (beginning from 2014) Jaishankar became FS and in the second term of the PM the then FS has been made Minister for External Affairs. Isn’t the chemistry incredible?

03 Jun 2019
modi-govt-2.0-outlining-a-growth-story:-drive-conveniently,-drive-easy

Modi Govt 2.0 outlining a growth story: Drive conveniently, drive easy

India needs an investment ranging from $5 to 10 trillion to develop its infrastructure, science, agriculture, industry, and commerce to a point where the per capita GDP improves from $2000 to $20,000 in the next 10 years. Where will, or could, this money come from? Only from the US, Europe, and East Asian countries like Japan and South Korea. Forget about China. Let it invest in Pakistan.

 

That being the reality, New Delhi may have to work really hard and pragmatically in the next few months to streamline its economic reform agenda and tune the foreign policy accordingly. The concept of economic nationalism is good, but it has to be distilled too often through pragmatism to turn on its potency.

 

Currently, Europe, which could be one of the major financiers to India's growth story, has been waiting helplessly for the last 15 years for a free trade agreement. Similar is the story of trade relations with the US which has expressed its great displeasure by withdrawing the GSP trade scheme. Trade relations with Japan and South Korea are good but not without creases. 

 

In all cases, irrelevant issues have been raised by negotiating officials. So the matter needs to be sorted out at the government and ministerial levels.

 

The US move to withdraw GSP on India's exports to that country has only added urgency to the matter of redefining India's relations with financing countries. No great achievements would be made if New Delhi tries to woo Chinese capital, which is already tied with financing India's adversaries and enemies.

 

The US president is known for his transactional nature. Since the US played a pivotal role in backing France-sponsored Western move to blacklist Masood Azhar by taking the issue to the larger UNSC, which would have made China explain the reasons for its 'constructive support' to Azhar, China blinked and backed off because it had no valid reasons for imposing its willful and malicious hold on Azhar's blacklisting.

 

For a much-needed favor shown to India, Trump naturally wants reciprocal favor. And like always, New Delhi is whining and grumbling. Instead of sending the new foreign minister Jaishankar to Washington to handle the matter urgently and negotiate a win-win deal on minor trade issues that could snowball into bigger problems, spinmasters are trying to convey that the move may not be much damaging.

 

The commerce ministry has said and believes that the GSP withdrawal may impact marginally as the total duty reduction under the scheme was only $190 million a year on the trade value of $6.3 billion. Since, in 2018, India had a goods trade surplus of $21.3 billion with the US, the ministry is not bothered about the fact that what begins as a trickle could become a powerful trend. Look at our trade deficit with China: it began as a trickle 15 years ago and now it costs a huge $70 billion that empowers China to freely finance our adversaries, enemies, and internal saboteurs.

 

New Delhi doesn't seem to have played its hands deftly during the first NaMo term 2014-19 on issues that concern the West, which remains the largest source of FDI, FPIs, technology, IT, and outsourcing businesses. In 2018, for instance, it created avoidable tax hurdles in the functioning of Amazon. It really sent out a wrong signal that it was being done to protect domestic e-commerce and other retail businesses. After the Vodafone incident, this was the second instance of creating unnecessary tax problems for major foreign operators. In both cases, the FinMin was run by lawyers.

 

So, in a sense, it's a great relief that the FinMin has come to be occupied by Nirmala Seetharaman who understands the complexities of global finance and business.

 

Looks like she may get adequate support from the new foreign minister who after retirement was put on probation in learning the ropes of international finance and trade at Tata Sons. This couldn't but have been done with an agreement between Ratan Tata and Narendra Modi. Possibly, Modi's first term taught him that he needed a foreign minister who could deal with global businesses as proficiently as he dealt with politics. And so, he must have organized Jaishankar's appointment on Tata Sons. 

(By M K Shukla & Rakesh Ranjan)

02 Jun 2019
pm-modi-&-jaishankar:-choice,-coincidences-and-chemistry

PM Modi & Jaishankar: Choice, coincidences and chemistry

By IndianMandarins 03 Jun 2019

Subrahmanyam Jaishankar (Retd IFS:1977), former External Affairs Secretary and a Padma Shri awardee, has brought quite a surprising element to NaMo Govt 2.0. In the past too he has been kicking off one surprise after the other. So a look at Jaishankar’s journey through the events that led to the peak of a career that is simply incredible:

 

First and foremost, he was the first choice of former PM Dr Manmohan Singh for the top job of India’s Ambassador to US (during civil nuke deal). When Narendra Modi took over, Jaishankar became the first choice of PM for Foreign Secretary. People in power corridors are abuzz of Jaishankar’s competence, contributions, attributes and ascent that more than once turned the choice to him irrespective of the change in political leadership of the country.

 

And there are yet a few more interesting coincidences:   

 

Jaishankar first displaced Foreign Secretary Sujata Singh (SS) to occupy the coveted post and later stepped into the shoes of foreign minister Sushma Swaraj (SS). Thus, he replaced one lady after the other and both have the initials SS – a strange coincidence.

 

Soon after he was announced to be part of Modi Cabinet news reports referred to him as retired Foreign Secretary. Most reporters forgot that he had joined the Tatas only few days after his superannuation. His entry to the top business house virtually laid a new precedent. And it is akin to the practice of revolving door which is common in the US. He was a Tata man for 18 months before becoming Minister; a new sort of lateral entry into the Cabinet? 

 

Jaishankar’s coming to the political executive is like that of Manmohan Singh when he suddenly became FM. Singh also went on to become PM. So who can say what is in store in case of Jaishankar?

 

Leave this aside for a moment and look at PM Modi’s spiritual connection with Shankar. The PM has twice been elected from Varanasi, the holy land of Shankar or Baba Vishwanath. During Modi 1.0 (beginning from 2014) Jaishankar became FS and in the second term of the PM the then FS has been made Minister for External Affairs. Isn’t the chemistry incredible?

modi-govt-2.0-outlining-a-growth-story:-drive-conveniently,-drive-easy

Modi Govt 2.0 outlining a growth story: Drive conveniently, drive easy

By IndianMandarins 02 Jun 2019

India needs an investment ranging from $5 to 10 trillion to develop its infrastructure, science, agriculture, industry, and commerce to a point where the per capita GDP improves from $2000 to $20,000 in the next 10 years. Where will, or could, this money come from? Only from the US, Europe, and East Asian countries like Japan and South Korea. Forget about China. Let it invest in Pakistan.

 

That being the reality, New Delhi may have to work really hard and pragmatically in the next few months to streamline its economic reform agenda and tune the foreign policy accordingly. The concept of economic nationalism is good, but it has to be distilled too often through pragmatism to turn on its potency.

 

Currently, Europe, which could be one of the major financiers to India's growth story, has been waiting helplessly for the last 15 years for a free trade agreement. Similar is the story of trade relations with the US which has expressed its great displeasure by withdrawing the GSP trade scheme. Trade relations with Japan and South Korea are good but not without creases. 

 

In all cases, irrelevant issues have been raised by negotiating officials. So the matter needs to be sorted out at the government and ministerial levels.

 

The US move to withdraw GSP on India's exports to that country has only added urgency to the matter of redefining India's relations with financing countries. No great achievements would be made if New Delhi tries to woo Chinese capital, which is already tied with financing India's adversaries and enemies.

 

The US president is known for his transactional nature. Since the US played a pivotal role in backing France-sponsored Western move to blacklist Masood Azhar by taking the issue to the larger UNSC, which would have made China explain the reasons for its 'constructive support' to Azhar, China blinked and backed off because it had no valid reasons for imposing its willful and malicious hold on Azhar's blacklisting.

 

For a much-needed favor shown to India, Trump naturally wants reciprocal favor. And like always, New Delhi is whining and grumbling. Instead of sending the new foreign minister Jaishankar to Washington to handle the matter urgently and negotiate a win-win deal on minor trade issues that could snowball into bigger problems, spinmasters are trying to convey that the move may not be much damaging.

 

The commerce ministry has said and believes that the GSP withdrawal may impact marginally as the total duty reduction under the scheme was only $190 million a year on the trade value of $6.3 billion. Since, in 2018, India had a goods trade surplus of $21.3 billion with the US, the ministry is not bothered about the fact that what begins as a trickle could become a powerful trend. Look at our trade deficit with China: it began as a trickle 15 years ago and now it costs a huge $70 billion that empowers China to freely finance our adversaries, enemies, and internal saboteurs.

 

New Delhi doesn't seem to have played its hands deftly during the first NaMo term 2014-19 on issues that concern the West, which remains the largest source of FDI, FPIs, technology, IT, and outsourcing businesses. In 2018, for instance, it created avoidable tax hurdles in the functioning of Amazon. It really sent out a wrong signal that it was being done to protect domestic e-commerce and other retail businesses. After the Vodafone incident, this was the second instance of creating unnecessary tax problems for major foreign operators. In both cases, the FinMin was run by lawyers.

 

So, in a sense, it's a great relief that the FinMin has come to be occupied by Nirmala Seetharaman who understands the complexities of global finance and business.

 

Looks like she may get adequate support from the new foreign minister who after retirement was put on probation in learning the ropes of international finance and trade at Tata Sons. This couldn't but have been done with an agreement between Ratan Tata and Narendra Modi. Possibly, Modi's first term taught him that he needed a foreign minister who could deal with global businesses as proficiently as he dealt with politics. And so, he must have organized Jaishankar's appointment on Tata Sons. 

(By M K Shukla & Rakesh Ranjan)

abhay-kumar-is-also-ambassador-of-india-to-comoros

Abhay Kumar is also Ambassador of India to Comoros

By IndianMandarins 28 May 2019

Abhay Kumar (IFS:2003) was on Tuesday concurrently accredited as the next Ambassador of India to the Union of the Comoros with residence in Antananarivo.. Presently he is Ambassador of India to the Republic of Madagascar. He is expected to take up the assignment shortly.

sanjiv-arora-is-secretary,-cpv&oia

Sanjiv Arora is Secretary, CPV&OIA

By IndianMandarins 08 Jan 2019

The Appointments Committee of the Cabinet appointed Sanjiv Arora (IFS:1984) to the post of Secretary, Consular, Passport, Visa & Overseas Indian Affairs (CPV&OIA) in the External Affairs Ministry. Presently, Sanjiv Arora serves is Ambassador in Lebanon.  

 

Arora will take over from Dnyaneshwar Mulay (IFS:1983) on 01 February 2019. It may be mentioned that the NaMo administration had, on 10 September 2018, given Mulay a fresh lease of career by re-appointing him on contract basis from December 1, 2018 to January 31, 2019. 

free stat counter

Indianmandarins.com, an initiative of New Media Network, is a multi-media initiative for the fast and real-time dissemination of news and information related to civil services, central PSUs and other institutions that play a critical role in governance, administration, corporate governance, and public life in India. We aspire to provide our esteemed readers with news breaks and situation analysis in the above-mentioned domain of operations. Currently, we are available at www.indianmandarins.com. We are now planning to branch off into print publication and few other related business initiatives.